Butter is an emulsion of water, fat, and dairy solids, so the trick to successfully using butter in baking is keeping the emulsion intact.
- Don’t defrost frozen butter in a microwave, as this will destroy the emulsion. Instead, cut it into chunks and leave it out until it’s cold but malleable.
- You know that butter is the right temperature if the cube easily bends without cracking or breaking, and unwrapping it leaves a bit of residue on the wrapper.
- When creaming butter in a mixer, it’s ideal to keep butter at around 65 degrees, or a consistency that’s spreadable.
- If the mixing bowl begins to warm, stick it in the freezer for a few minutes to keep butter’s emulsion intact.
- To get cookies to hold their shape and edge, chill or freeze the dough before baking.
- For flakier pastries, pre-chill your utensils and use a cold marble surface for rolling.
- Using your fingers to cut butter into flour can cause the butter to melt. Instead, use a food processor. If you don’t own one, use a box cheese grater to shred the butter, and then a pastry blender or two flatware knives to combine the butter and flour.
Butter contributes to the texture of baked goods through the aeration process.
- When a recipe calls for creaming butter, let your mixer whip the butter for three minutes.
- During the creaming process, keep your mixer at a relatively low speed; mixing at high speed increases the possibility that the butter will heat up and lose its emulsion.
- If butter is too hard, it won’t aerate properly, so make sure it’s soft enough to be malleable.
The variety of butter you use sometimes – but not always – produces different results in baking.
- Although American butters, European butters, and artisanal butters often have inherently different flavors, those distinctions usually fade away when butter is used as an ingredient in baking.
- American butter must have a fat content of at least 80%, while French butter must contain a minimum of 82% fat. Some butters strive for 85% fat. The higher the fat content, the less water the butter contains, making pastries flakier.
See also quick tips for sauces, compound butters, general cooking, and clarified butter.
Help grow this exhibit! Join in the fun by sending your favorite tips for baking with butter, or your tried-and-true recipes. Read more about sharing your tips and recipes.